From Yuma, Arizona, I've seen with interest the story about Dr. Jon Cooper and his son Dan who used an ATV to clear snow from their neighbours' sidewalks. I believe the RCMP has lost an incredible opportunity to score Brownie points at a time when public perception of the force is very low.
What if the RCMP had used their cruisers to block traffic for a short time while the Coopers pulled their ATV from the snowbank? The whole community would have applauded their sensitivity. We all know that police have considerable discretion in charging people with offences and although the city has a bylaw that prohibits using an ATV within city limits, most of us understand that there are mitigating circumstances in this case. We've not talking about someone using an ATV to ride through city streets year-round. Dr. Cooper was providing a service to his neighbourhood, which includes many seniors, at a time when they needed it.
I feel it is unfortunate that the situation was allowed to escalate to the point where charges have been laid. No doubt tempers flared, but the police, in this situation, could have used their position of authority to calm the situation, provide the help required and allow the Coopers to carry on with their service to their community. Is that not what St. Albert is all about?
Unfortunately, the city has been portrayed on national news as a community that follows the letter, rather than the intent, of the law and where consideration is not given in cases where individuals are attempting to better their community.
I would suggest that, rather than laying charges, the police should be awarding a medal for community service.
Jeanne Mackenzie, St. Albert
